With the recent release of the Hobbit: Desolation of Smaug, I have decided to post my review of the best fantasy epic not set in the land of Middle Earth, Princess Mononoke.
Thoughts: Princess Mononoke, often considered to be one of the best films from famed animation director Hayao Miyazaki and Studio Ghibli. For those not familiar with Hayao Miyazaki, he is regarded as one of the top filmmakers in all of cinema, and the best among animation. He is the mastermind behind films like Spirited Away, Howl's Moving Castle, and, of course, Princess Mononoke. His anime films are some of the few that have had success in America, and Princess Mononoke was one of his first to be successful in America.
While I am a anime fan, Princess Mononoke is the first Hayao Miyazaki and Studio Ghibli film I have seen. Despite the film's critical acclaim, my expectations were rather low. However, Princess Mononoke turned out to be a giant surprise because it is not only one of the best anime films I have seen, it is one of the best films ever made. Princess Mononoke is a fantasy adventure of epic portions that easily ranks among the best of both the fantasy and animation genres. While the name of the film would suggest Princess Mononoke is a family or children's film, that is not the case. In terms of content, the film is similar to that of the Lord of the Rings. Although never overly gory, the film does have some decapitations, blood, and the chopping off of limbs.
Princess Mononoke is about Ashitaka, the last prince of the Emishi tribe whose traveling companion is Yakul, a red elk, and his journey to remove the curse, which give him unexpected abilities. On his journey various things happen and it turns into an "Unexpected Journey." The tone of the film is somewhat melancholic, but never overly dull and overall very serious.
Directed by: Hayao Miyazaki
Genre: Fantasy, Action Adventure, Epic, Animation, Anime,
Release Date: July 12, 1997
Running Time:133 minutes
MMPA rating: PG-13
The Good: Original concept, Charming animation, Unexpectedly impressive action scenes, Sweeping epic story, Engaging story and atmosphere, Unique fantasy setting, Mostly strong English dub, Epic action scenes, Surprisingly dark, Great world building, Perfect pacing,
The Bad: Somewhat weird ending, Overstated environmentalist message,
Plot: 9.8/10- Princess Mononoke appears to be a seemingly simple story at first; however the film turns into an epic fantasy adventure on a grand scale. Every aspect of the story is well developed including the characters, plot, and setting. The world building is executed expertly and never seems to delve into overly expository content. Many of the characters are morally ambiguous, with multiple characters all having their own goals. While the first 15 minutes of the film is not entirely capture my attention, after that, I was engrossed in the film and the world it created. The pacing is absolutely spot on, with just the right amount of action and story. In many ways, the film reminds me of a mix of Seven Samurai and the Hobbit (minus the goofy humor) in terms of its scope and scale. Even though there is a lot to like about Princess Mononoke, I do have a few minor problems. One being the odd ending, which went a little too far into the Japanese mythology for my taste. The ending is nearly as weird as something like Akira, but it is a little off putting. My other problem is that the film's environmentalist message was too heavy handed and felted forced at times. While it is not nearly as overstated and poorly implemented as Avatar, which obviously is influenced by Princess Mononoke, the themes are unnecessarily prominent.
Action: 9.5/10- To my surprise, Princess Mononoke is actually an action film to some degree. Ashitaka has several impressively animated fight scenes. The attention to detail during the large battles is fantastic, and the fluidity of animation during the battles is excellent. While not the best action I have seen in anime, the action serves the story very well.
Acting: 9.2/10- While mostly strong, Princess Mononoke's English dub does have some problems. At first, the dub was difficult to become accustomed to. However, after 20 minutes into the film, I started to enjoy the dub. Billy Crudup as Ashitaka gave a very strong performance and added many layers to his character. Claire Danes was also very strong as the conflicted San (Princess Mononoke). Minnie Driver as Lady Eboshi easily gave the strongest performance of the supporting cast. Billy Bob Thornton's performance as Jiko-bō was a little dodgy at times, and lacked consistency. Keith David lends his recognizable strong voice to the film and gives an overall strong performance. Overall, the rest of the supporting cast is hit and miss. Some performances are fine, others could have been better.
Art Style: 9.5/10- At first, the animation was not particularly appealing to me. However, after watching the first 30 minutes, it started to grow on me. The attention to detail is immaculate and the fluidity of the animation is superb. A few of the character models are not my favorite, which is my general problem with what I have seen of Studio Ghibli's work; however, as with the rest of the animation, they started to grow on me. According to what I have read, some computer generated 3D is used, however it is barely noticeable, which is fantastic.
Soundtrack: 9.9/10- Princess Mononoke has a positively beautiful score by Joe Hisaishi. During the landscape frames, the soundtrack perfectly compliments the sweeping scope of the film. The score combines a few Japanese sounding notes with a fantasy like score. It reminds of something I have heard before but I cannot place. Below is the complete soundtrack.
Comedy: 5.8/10- Although there is some humor, Princess Mononoke is a mostly serious film.
Would I Watch This Again: Yes, most definitely yes; Princess Mononoke is a film that I will rewatch.
Overall: 9.5/10- Overall Princess Mononoke is an amazing fantasy epic, and while not for everyone, it is a film that has to be experienced for yourself.
Closing comments: Aside of films set in Middle Earth, Princess Mononoke might just be the best fantasy epic ever created, and to my surprise, it is one of my new favorite films.
If you want read more anime reviews, please check out my reviews of Code Geass, Death Note, and The Girl Who Leapt Through Time and, if enough readers are interested, I have several more anime series and movies reviews like Steins;Gate, Ghost in the Shell, Perfect Blue, Cowboy Bebop, and more.
If you want read more anime reviews, please check out my reviews of Code Geass, Death Note, and The Girl Who Leapt Through Time and, if enough readers are interested, I have several more anime series and movies reviews like Steins;Gate, Ghost in the Shell, Perfect Blue, Cowboy Bebop, and more.
Also check out Arvin Saints' review of Princess Mononoke on his blog Anime and Book Messiah. If you are interested in anime or books, check out his blog, I highly recommend it.
Recommended for: Fantasy fans, Action Adventure fans, Epic fans, Animation fans, Anime fans,
If you want to contact us or have any question please send an e-mail to johnstarslayer@gmail.com.
I'm glad you gave it a 9.5! It really is amazing in almost every aspect, and it is obvious that it has greatly influenced anime in general. I think it's somewhat unfair to judge its comedic aspect, since that's really not the juice of the movie. But I get your point.
ReplyDeletePrincess Mononoke is perhaps the Miyazaki film closest to my heart. It is the one that introduced me to him, not to mention that it has a subtle way of getting in to you, in a manner that you'll feel like a changed person after watching it -- something that I only felt in Neon Genesis Evangelion, Fate/Zero, and Madoka Magica.
And hey, thanks for linking it to my blog! I'm looking forward to your other reviews.
The comedic aspect rating does not effect the overall rating of serious films like Mononoke, but I include it so that readers will know if a film has humor in it. Hopefully that makes sense.
DeleteI agree with you, it is right there with the anime that have affected me the most as well, like Death Note and Code Geass for me, and Fate/Zero will be up there after I finish it.
No problem, glad to do it!
-James
Great review! I agree, this film is definitely very, very well done(it's definitely one of my favorite films, and one of my top favorites of Miyazaki's work); I also wish the message had been a bit more subtle- I agree with the message, but as an artist I like a to figure out the message behind something.
ReplyDeleteMiyazaki definitely has a way with fiction, and he always has interesting, different films. None of them are copies of the other, and his films can make a story I'd find not to my liking otherwise, into something actually very good.
If you ever watch any of his other films, I hope you enjoy them :)
It is rare that a filmmaker never makes a sequel and I respect Miyazaki for that, which has a lot to do with how his movies are always so different. I have seen a couple more of his movies, which were very good, and I plan to watch Spirited Away soon. :)
Delete-James
Well! I think I must see this one since you are recommending it so highly!! I will look for it on Netflix as soon as possible; it sounds quite interesting. I hope I like it. :) Once again, another great review!
ReplyDelete~Jamie
I am not entirely sure if you will like the movie or not, however I would say give it a try. It is one of those classic movies that need to be seen. Thanks Jamie! :)
Delete-James
I'm glad you liked the movie!!!! ^-^ Though, I have to agree: people who are unable to handle other religions shouldn't watch this. I really liked the Japanese culture that was in the movie, because it showed how unique a different country is through their movies. :D
ReplyDeleteThe music was AMAZING!!!!! And I'm glad you liked it!
~Misty
Actually, I did not see a lot religion in the film myself. It reminded me a lot of old mythology like Norse or Geek, except it is just Japanese, although I suppose mythology is based on religion. Anyway, I also like Japanese culture to a certain extent, particularly Samurai and the warrior code type thing.
DeleteJoe Hisaishi's score was amazing; I listened to it a lot after finishing the movie! :)
-James
Really? I guess I see so much mythology/religion in anime, it's easy for me to pick out in films and tv shows. XD
DeleteSamurai are definitely a plus in Japanese culture. I also love the way they dress when going to battle. :D
I KNOW!!! I always listen to soundtracks after the movie because they're sooo amazing. Especially if they are made up of a complete orchestra. ^-^ I can't wait to hear what you think of his other films! Try watching Nausicaa! (If you haven't already. :P )
~Misty
Great review, though if you watch it again I recommend checking it out with the original japanese audio. It's much better than the dub and you'd be surprised how different certain characters seem.
ReplyDeleteThank you Banon, and thanks, that is a great idea, I will have to have to watch the sub when I re-watch the movie.
Delete-James